Comparative Literature Review Essays

A comparative review may, e.g., require you to examine two schools of thought, two issues, or the positions taken by two persons. You may create a hierarchy of issues and sub-issues to compare and contrast, as suggested by the following general plan.

This model lists 3 options for structuring the body of the review. In all cases, you are expected to deal with the similarities (compare) and then with the differences (contrast): Introduction, Body, & Conclusion

Introduction: Opening Paragraph(s) Introduce your overall topic

Establish the significance of the topic/subject

Identify the main problem/issue/theory you'll focus on

Briefly identify the positions/authors you'll review, and where they differ or complement each other

Body
(3 sample Options)

Examine theory/view A

Examine theory/view B

Compare and contrast A & B

Similarities of
A & B

Differences of
A & B

Discussion of central issues

Issue 1: Discuss A & B

Issue 2: Discuss A & B

Issue 3: Discuss
A & B

Conclusion (Options)

Conclusion that ranks one theory/position over the other

Conclusion that summarises the respective merits of each theory or position

Literature Review Example 3 offers an excellent example of  a comparative review [Language and gender]. This was written by Alastair Pennycook for his undergraduate students as a model of (among other things) of how to structure a  review of the literature - for an example of the above structure.